Expert Tips to Resolve 6 Common Maytag Fridge Problems in 2025

1. The Refrigerator Isn’t Cooling but the Light Is On

If your Maytag fridge is not cooling properly but the light inside is still on, here are a few things you can check to resolve the issue.

• Check the temperature settings: Ensure that the temperature settings on your refrigerator are set correctly. Sometimes, the settings may have been accidentally changed, causing the cooling problem. Refer to your refrigerator’s user manual for instructions on how to adjust the temperature settings.
• Clean the condenser coils: Dust and debris can accumulate on the condenser coils, hindering their ability to release heat and cool the fridge. Use a vacuum cleaner or a soft brush to gently clean the coils. Be sure to unplug the refrigerator before attempting to clean the coils.
• Inspect the door gaskets: Damaged or worn-out door gaskets can cause cool air to escape from the refrigerator, leading to cooling issues. Check the gaskets for any signs of wear, cracks, or gaps. If you notice any damage, consider replacing the gaskets to ensure a proper seal.

By following these steps, you can troubleshoot common cooling problems with your Maytag refrigerator. If the issue persists, schedule refrigerator repair service and we’ll send a Sears Home Services technician to your home to fix the problem.

2. The Ice Maker Isn’t Making Enough Ice

If you’re experiencing issues with your Maytag fridge’s ice maker not producing enough ice, follow these expert tips to help resolve the problem.

• Check the water supply: Start by ensuring that the water supply to the fridge is properly connected and turned on. Make sure there are no kinks or blockages in the water line. If the water supply is restricted, it can affect ice production.
• Inspect the ice maker assembly: Take a look at the ice maker assembly inside the freezer compartment. Check for any visible obstructions or ice buildup that may be preventing the ice maker from functioning properly. Clear away any debris or ice buildup that you find.
• Clean the ice maker: Over time, mineral deposits can accumulate in the ice maker, affecting its performance. To clean it, follow the manufacturer’s instructions in your Maytag fridge’s user manual. Typically, you’ll need to remove the ice maker and clean it with a mild cleaning solution. Be sure to rinse it thoroughly before reinstalling it.

By checking the water supply, inspecting the ice maker assembly, and cleaning the ice maker, you can often resolve the issue of your Maytag fridge not making enough ice. If the problem persists, set up a service appointment for refrigerator repair.

3. Condensation in the Fridge or Frost in the Freezer

If you’re experiencing condensation in the fridge or frost in the freezer of your Maytag refrigerator, here are a few troubleshooting tips you can try to resolve this common issue.

• Check the door seals: One of the most common causes of condensation or frost buildup is improper sealing of the refrigerator doors. Inspect the door seals for any signs of damage or wear. If you notice any cracks, tears, or gaps, it’s time to replace the seals. This simple fix can help maintain the temperature inside the fridge and freezer, preventing moisture buildup.
• Ensure proper airflow: Blocked airflow can also lead to condensation or frost issues. Make sure there’s enough space around the refrigerator to allow proper ventilation. Avoid overcrowding the fridge or freezer, as this can restrict airflow and cause temperature imbalances. Additionally, check the vents inside the fridge and freezer compartments to ensure they’re not obstructed by food items.
• Defrost the freezer: Over time, ice can accumulate in the freezer, leading to frost buildup. If you notice excessive frost, it’s essential to defrost the freezer. Unplug the refrigerator and remove all the food items from the freezer and refrigerator. Store the foods safely. Leave the freezer door open to allow the ice to melt naturally. Once the ice has melted, clean the freezer and dry it thoroughly before plugging the refrigerator back in and reloading the food.

By following these expert tips, you can resolve condensation and frost issues in your Maytag refrigerator, ensuring optimal performance and extending its lifespan. If the problem persists or you require further assistance, don’t hesitate to contact our professional technicians at Sears Home Services. We’re here to help!

4. The Refrigerator Is Making Noise

When your Maytag fridge is making unusual noises, it can be quite bothersome. However, there are a few simple steps you can take to resolve this issue.

• Check for loose or worn-out parts: Start by inspecting the refrigerator for any loose or worn-out parts. This could include screws, hinges, or brackets. Tighten or replace any parts that appear to be damaged or unstable. This can help eliminate rattling or banging noises.
• Clean the condenser fan: The condenser fan plays a crucial role in the cooling process of your fridge. Over time, dust and debris can accumulate on the fan blades, causing it to make loud noises. Turn off the refrigerator and locate the condenser fan at the back or bottom of the unit. Use a soft brush or cloth to gently clean the fan blades, removing any dirt or buildup.
• Level the refrigerator: A refrigerator that is not properly leveled can also lead to noise issues. Check if your fridge is sitting level on the floor. If it’s tilted or uneven, adjust the leveling legs or use shims to stabilize it. This can help reduce vibrations and noise caused by an unbalanced appliance.

By following these expert tips, you can easily troubleshoot and resolve common noise problems with your Maytag refrigerator. If the issue persists or you require professional assistance, don’t hesitate to contact our team of skilled technicians at Sears Home Services.

5. The Water Dispenser Isn’t Working Properly

When you’re experiencing issues with your Maytag fridge’s water dispenser, there are a few troubleshooting steps you can take to resolve the problem. Here are some expert tips to help you get your water dispenser working properly again:

• Check the dispenser settings: See if the control lock is enabled. If it is, turn the control lock off. You’ll typically need to press and hold a certain button that is marked on the dispenser control panel to turn off the control lock. Refer to the owner’s manual for your Maytag fridge if you need help disabling the control lock.
• Replace the water filter: Most Maytag refrigerators have a water filter that needs replacing every six months. Replace the water filter if you haven’t installed a new one within the last year. Be sure that you purge 1 gallon of water through the water dispenser after replacing the filter to avoid drips from the dispenser due to air trapped in the water line system after replacing the filter.
• Check the water supply line: Inspect the water supply line connected to your fridge. Ensure that it is securely connected and not kinked or blocked. Sometimes, a simple repositioning or replacement of the water supply line can fix the issue.

By following these expert tips, you can troubleshoot and resolve common water dispenser problems with your Maytag fridge. If the issue persists or you need further assistance, don’t hesitate to reach out to our experienced technicians at Sears Home Services. We have a team of experts who can help diagnose and fix any Maytag fridge problems.

6. The Compressor Is Short Cycling

If you’re experiencing issues with your Maytag fridge’s compressor short cycling, there are a few troubleshooting steps you can take to resolve the problem. Short cycling occurs when the compressor turns on and off frequently, which can lead to improper cooling and potential damage to the unit. Here are some expert tips to help you address this issue:

• Check for electrical issues: Start by inspecting the power cord. Make sure that the power cord is plugged in securely and isn’t damaged. Check the electrical outlet for proper power by plugging in a small appliance or night light. If the light or small appliance doesn’t work properly, have an electrician repair the electrical outlet.
• Clean the condenser coils: Dust buildup on the condenser coils will hinder their ability to dissipate heat effectively. Use a refrigerator coil brush and vacuum cleaner to carefully clean the coils so the compressor doesn’t overheat.
• Inspect the condenser fan: The condenser fan blows air across the condenser coils. If the condenser fan isn’t running, the compressor may short cycle. If the condenser fan isn’t running while the compressor short cycles, unplug the fridge and check the wire harness plug on the compressor fan. Plug in the connection securely if it's loose or disconnected.

By following these expert tips, you can troubleshoot and resolve the short cycling problem with your Maytag fridge. If the issue persists or you require further assistance, don’t hesitate to contact our experienced technicians at Sears Home Services. We are here to provide you with reliable solutions for all your appliance repair needs.

Schedule Annual Preventive Maintenance to Help Prevent Maytag Fridge Problems

Annual preventive refrigerator maintenance by a Sears Home Services technician will help prevent Maytag fridge problems throughout the year. During cleaning and maintenance service, our tech will perform many of the tasks listed above and check all components of your Maytag fridge to identify any potential issues before they cause cooling or operation problems.

Having your Maytag fridge professionally cleaned and maintained every year will also help it last longer.

Schedule your refrigerator cleaning and maintenance service now.