8 Common Mistakes People Make When Buying a Refrigerator & How to Avoid Them

4 min readUpdated Feb. 27, 2025Kimberly HillegassRefrigerator
8 Common Mistakes People Make When Buying a Refrigerator

A refrigerator is one of the most important appliances in your home. It keeps your food fresh and serves as a centerpiece in your kitchen. But with so many styles, features, and considerations, buying a fridge can feel overwhelming. This guide highlights the most common mistakes people make and gives you the tools to avoid them, ensuring you choose the perfect refrigerator for your needs.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Measure Before You Buy: Always measure your space, including width, height, depth, and door clearance, to ensure the fridge fits properly in your kitchen.
  • Pick the Right Style for Your Needs: Choose a refrigerator style that suits your habits, such as top-freezer, side-by-side, or French door, and consider extra features you’ll actually use.
  • Think Long-Term with Energy Efficiency: Energy-efficient models might cost more upfront, but they’ll save you money on utility bills and are better for the environment.

A refrigerator is a big investment that will be with you for 10+ years. Choosing the right one can make your life easier, while choosing poorly can lead to years of frustration—or even the need for costly repairs. Avoid these common mistakes to ensure you get the perfect fridge for your dream kitchen.

1. Choosing the Wrong Style

Not all refrigerators are the same. While they all keep your food cold, their style can impact how convenient they are in daily use.

  • Consider your needs: Do you prefer a top-freezer, bottom-freezer, side-by-side, or French door fridge?
  • Think about features: Would you use a built-in water or ice dispenser?

Choose a style that matches your daily habits and fits your kitchen layout.

2. Forgetting to Measure Your Space

This mistake can turn excitement into disappointment when your new fridge doesn’t fit your kitchen.

  • Measure carefully: Take note of the width, height, and depth of your fridge space.
  • Check door clearance: Make sure the doors and drawers can fully open without bumping into walls, cabinets, or islands.
  • Leave breathing room: Leave at least an inch of space around the fridge for ventilation.

Failing to measure properly could also lead to improper installation, which can increase wear and tear.

3. Skipping Door Swing Considerations

Even if the fridge fits your space, the way the doors open can be a problem.

  • Check for obstructions: Will the doors hit walls, counters, or other appliances?
  • Think about convenience: Ensure drawers can be fully extended without any obstacles.

4. Ignoring Energy Efficiency

Many people avoid energy-efficient models because they cost more upfront. However, they can save you money over time.

  • Look for the Energy Star label: Energy-efficient fridges use less power and reduce monthly electricity bills.
  • Think long-term: The savings on energy bills can outweigh the initial cost over the appliance’s lifespan.

Energy-efficient models are also better for the environment.

5. Overlooking the Importance of Finish and Style

Your refrigerator should be functional but also complement your kitchen design.

  • Match your appliances: Choose a finish that matches other appliances (stainless steel, black, white, etc.).
  • Consider fingerprints: If you want less cleaning hassle, look for fingerprint-resistant finishes.

A mismatched or hard-to-maintain finish can take away from your kitchen’s appeal.

6. Focusing Only on Features You Don’t Use

Modern refrigerators often come with fancy features, but they’re only worth it if you’ll actually use them.

  • Avoid unnecessary extras: Don’t pay for built-in screens, Wi-Fi, or advanced cooling zones unless they’ll genuinely improve your experience.
  • Prioritize usability: Focus on features that make daily tasks easier, like adjustable shelves or ample freezer space.

Too many unnecessary features can mean more parts that could break down.

7. Not Planning for Delivery and Installation

Even the perfect fridge can turn into a hassle if delivery isn’t planned properly.

  • Check for obstacles: Ensure the fridge can fit through doorways, hallways, and staircases.
  • Plan installation: Will you need professional help to set it up?

Improper installation can lead to performance issues.

8. Failing to Recycle the Old Fridge

Improper disposal of your old refrigerator can harm the environment and create unnecessary waste.

  • Recycle responsibly: Contact a service to recycle your old appliance.
  • Prevent harmful chemicals: Recycling prevents chemicals like Freon from leaking into the environment.

Proper disposal keeps your community clean and eco-friendly.

Final Thoughts

Buying a refrigerator is a major decision, but avoiding these common mistakes can make the process smoother. Measure your space, choose a style that fits your needs, and consider energy-efficient models for long-term savings. Don’t forget to plan for delivery and recycle your old fridge responsibly.

If your refrigerator ever needs servicing, Sears Home Services can help. Our expert technicians provide reliable and affordable refrigerator repair, ensuring your appliance runs smoothly for years to come. Whether it’s a quick fix or a major repair, Sears Home Services is here to help keep your fridge in top shape.

Frequently Asked Questions

What mistakes do shoppers often make?
Picking the wrong size, ignoring energy ratings, or overlooking door swing space. Sears Home Services can help measure and recommend the right specs.
Why is door swing so important?
A fridge door that hits counters or walls is impractical. Sears Home Services ensures your chosen model fits your kitchen layout perfectly.
Are warranties worth it?
They can save money on unexpected repairs. Sears Home Services also offers extended warranties and repair plans for added peace of mind.
Is matching brand and style crucial?
While not mandatory, a cohesive kitchen design can boost resale value. Sears Home Services can align the style of your new fridge with other appliances.

Schedule your refrigerator repair now!

Backed by years of experience, our technicians possess the skills necessary to fix your refrigerator. And because our techs our local, they can fix it for you fast.

Call (213) 596-2538 or schedule online now.
Text (240) 616-1772 to schedule now.

Was this information helpful?

Schedule your refrigerator repair now!

Text (240) 616-1772

Repair Refrigerator Resources

Banner image for blog article "Why is my Samsung Fridge not Cooling but the Freezer Works?"
4 min readMar. 28

Find out why your Samsung fridge is not cooling but the freezer section works. Get expert troubleshooting tips to fix the problem.

Banner image for blog article "Why the Fridge is not Cold but the Freezer Is,"
7 min readMar. 27

Find out why the fridge is not cool but the freezer is and learn how to troubleshoot the common problems that cause this failure.

Banner image for blog article "Why is my Refrigerator Working but the Freezer is not Freezing?"
4 min readMar. 25

Find out what to do when the freezer is not freezing but the fridge works fine. Fix the problem fast with our expert DIY troubleshooting tips.

Banner image for blog article "Why is my Whirlpool Fridge not Cooling but the Freezer Works?"
8 min readMar. 13

Find out why Whirlpool fridge is not cooling but the freezer works and learn how to troubleshoot the common problems that cause this failure.

Glossary Terms

A dual ice maker is a feature in some refrigerators that includes two separate ice makers: one in the fridge compartment and another in the freezer section. This setup doubles the appliance's ice-making capacity.

A French-door refrigerator features two doors that open side-by-side on the top section for the refrigerator compartment, with a bottom freezer drawer, combining style, efficiency, and easy access to both refrigerated and frozen goods.

Refrigerant is a chemical compound used in HVAC systems and refrigerators to absorb heat from the environment by cycling through states of evaporation and condensation, enabling the cooling process through its cycle of evaporation and condensation.

R-12 refrigerant, also known as Freon-12, is a chlorofluorocarbon (CFC) compound that was once widely used in air conditioning systems, refrigerators, and aerosol propellants before its phase-out due to environmental concerns.

Common Repair Refrigerator Symptoms

The most common reasons your Kenmore Elite refrigerator stopped working are a locked compressor, damaged evaporator or a defective electronic control board.

The most common reasons your Maytag refrigerator stopped working are a locked compressor, damaged evaporator or a defective electronic control board.

The most common reasons your Kenmore refrigerator is noisy are a faulty ice maker assembly, defective electronic control board or a locked compressor.

The most common reasons your Kenmore refrigerator fan is not working are a defective electronic control board, damaged evaporator or a locked compressor.

The most common reasons your Whirlpool refrigerator fan is not working are a defective electronic control board, damaged evaporator or a locked compressor.

The most common reasons your Whirlpool refrigerator is not making ice but the water works are a faulty icemaker assembly, a defective water valve, or a malfunctioning PCB.